An alternative reading of "' - We Also
Walk Dogs'" (see here) is that, despite being listed in the Time Chart and
despite being included in a Future History collection, it does not really fit
into Heinlein's Future History. Its newly invented gravity control technology is
not mentioned in later stories where it would have made a difference. It refers
to seven extra-terrestrial races in the Solar System whereas other Future
History stories mention only two: Martians in "Ordeal in Space," Venerians in
"Logic of Empire" and both in "The Green Hills of Earth." Further, these
Martians and Venerians seem unlikely to engage in the kind of interplanetary
power politics suggested by " '- We Also Walk Dogs.'" The story mentions Luna City
but a lunar colony of that name could exist in almost any future involving space
travel.
Because the Future History is a series,
not a serial, most of its installments could be read and assessed separately.
"Common Sense" is a sequel to "Universe" and "The Man Who Sold The Moon" was
written as a prequel to "Requiem." The latter, about Harriman's death, would
have remained a valid story even if Heinlein had not later added the longer
account of Harriman's earlier career.
If "' - We Also Walk Dogs'" is read
separately, then it need not be seen as leading to the worsening political
conditions of "Logic of Empire." Instead, its protagonists look forward to
profiting from the application of the "O'Neil effect" to space navigation,
colonization and recreation. One comments that, "There's always money in giving
people what they want." That sounds like a utopian future for all: the public
gets what it wants and their suppliers get "...gobs of money..." in the process.
In practice, of course, many members of the public might not be able to afford
luxury items and a market economy can be guaranteed not to expand indefinitely
but we still seem to be looking at a brighter future than the one described in
the ensuing episodes of the History.
No comments:
Post a Comment